Translate Manga for Manga bucks
Posted on 04. Oct, 2007 @ 11:45 am by harvey in Culture, Language, Media
Manganovel Corproation and Toshiba Corporation are using what seems to be a form of “crowd sourcing” and “Web 2.0″ to get Manga fans to translate Manga for them.
[source article on Yahoo News Asia]
The web based service is called “Manganovel” and allows readers to download manga in Japanese to read, and then post their translations back to the Manganovel. Submitted translations earn points that can then be used to purcahse more manga.
If you love manga and want to get some translation experience, but are not ready to get a serious translation job, this might be a good way to get your feet wet.
Checking the economics though, no one is going to get rich, or even get a lot of free manga out of this program.
The “Manganovel” Concept
1. Members buy Japanese version of comics for $4 to $5.
2. “Reader-translators” translate the comic to other languages.
3. The “reader translator” e-mails the “translation” to “Manganovel” and can price it at either free or 2 percent of the original comic price.
4. Readers can purchase the original Japanese comic and the translation data.
5. If a translation is purchased, the “reader-translator” gets 50% of the sale price as a royalty.
6. Readers who purchase translations can review them on “Manganovel’s” discussion board, and use reviews to select a translation of a comic from among multiple translations. The original “reader-translator” can also use the feedback from discussions to revise the text and try to improve it.
2% huh? Ouch!
I guess if you became “The Guru” who provides the best translations quickly for a particular popular manga, I could potentially imagine sustained sales continuing for a long long time… But still, it would take an incredibly high volume of sales for 2% of a 5 dollar manga to amount to anything significant. And also, it seems that you have to purchase the manga from their site to even begin the translation…
Would be fun though!
- Harvey
11 Responses to “Translate Manga for Manga bucks”
Leave a Reply
Welcome to JapanNewbie.com! My goal is to get you excited about Japan and the Japanese language. Love it! This blog has been around for more than five years now, so be sure to dig into the archives and use the search. You never know what you might find!
Recent Comments:
- A Friend to Chop your Head Off (1)
- locohama: Hell, what are friends for…good post!
- Foreigner Radio Taisou Fun (1)
- David: I work at a company that does this. Every day at 3pm on the dot (even weekends). Everyone ignores it. http://mdid.wordpress.com/2...
- Ferriss on how he learned Japanese, and other stuff (1)
- Kanjiwarrior: I’m very impressed with this guy. Seems like he’s really smart about breaking stuff down to the essentials. I really...
- Japanese Wedding Gifts (14)
- vita: hey, nice article! btw, what kanji is usually written in the hikidemono? i found out it is “御礼” (onrei) but what are the others...
- Traditional Japanese Home in the City (10)
- M.....: ohhh… we have lots of japanese homes like that 1 story and 2 here. and i live in california!!! lol =D
Thomas (nihonhacks.com)
Oct 4th, 2007
at 13:51
You misspelled “Manga” in your post title. Might want to fix that real quick :)
Harvey
Oct 4th, 2007
at 14:25
Thanks for the heads-up. Now I’ll have to figure out how to rebuild the URL. Probably easy, will do later ;-)
claytonian
Oct 4th, 2007
at 15:53
Intriguing. If I had more free time…
Buy & Translate Manga, Buy More Manga : Japan Probe
Oct 4th, 2007
at 16:15
[...] Japan Newbie has noted, the money users earn back for their hard work is incredibly tiny, so nobody should expect to make [...]
Thomas
Oct 4th, 2007
at 17:18
for rebuilding the url, in your WP admin go to Manage->Posts->Edit and then look for “post slug” on the right side. Editing the url might break some links though (like JapanProbe’s link to your site in the pingback above).
Harvey
Oct 4th, 2007
at 17:38
And as I’m sure you know, a JapanProbe link is not a link I’m looking to break! JapanProbe is the One Piece of JapanBlogs… because One Piece is an insanely popular managa… and JapanProbe is an insanely popular blog… okay. Strange analogy.
Chrissy
Oct 5th, 2007
at 06:43
Wow, cool! I just might give it a try!! That way I don’t forget my Japanese also!!
Chrissy
Oct 5th, 2007
at 06:58
none of the mangas they have look that interesting :( maybe if they will expand their database…
Heather Meadows
Oct 5th, 2007
at 22:29
I had an idea slightly similar to this for getting anime translated by fans, but in my scenario the translators at least got the raw materials for free :>
It looks like the translators get 50% of the fee when anyone buys the translation, too…wonder how much the company charges people for it? But you’re right, they’re only guaranteed that 2% of the comic price.
harvey
Oct 5th, 2007
at 22:56
Chrissy says all the manga there aren’t very interesting.. and Chrissy knows her manga!
What everyone else? Are there any interesting-looking manga there?
vince in tokyo
Feb 26th, 2009
at 02:28
These guys are raping the public for translation work that they will publish and make a lot of money off of – AND they’re charging the translator for the “opportunity” . . .
Silliness …