JET ALT/CIR Interview – Part 3

Posted on 24. Sep, 2007 @ 10:50 pm by in Culture, Society, Working Views: 1,062

We’ll continue the interview with Sugu, the JET teacher in Hamamatsu now. If you missed it, be sure to check out part 1 and part 2! In this interview Sugu comments on the JET selection process, as well as what causes some JET’s to stay… Forever… and what causes others to leave after the first year.

Q: Now that you have seen many other JETs come and go, have you noticed any similar characteristics in those who opt to stay longer than the initial one year contract, and those who, like your self, chose to extend?

One year is definitely too short on the JET Programme. ALTs tend to spend the first 6 months of that year just trying to stay afloat and by the time they start to get in the groove, they have to leave. However, some ALTs leave their home for an expressed one year sabbatical (Canadian teachers, specifically) and have a reason to stay in Japan for only one year.

After 2 years, ALTs that are ready to leave are usually the ones who are looking at grad school and want to do something completely different that may never put them in a classroom again. These are generally the people that don’t really care about teaching, they just wanted to try something different.

People that stay for 3 years are generally the type of people who are either looking at JET like a real job or using it as an excuse to stay making good money and do nothing. But these are broad sweeping generalizations. I’ve seen too many different types of ALTs to name them all.

Q: So which 3 year clan do you claim? Real job? Or money making do nothing excuse?

I fit into another category all together. I want to leave and go back to the States (I’ve only been back once in 3 years and that was not the best experience), but I can’t. I treat my position as a real job and thus work very hard at it. After all, my job is to manage other people’s lives and I certainly don’t want to see them crash here. But before that, when I was an ALT(Assistant Language Teacher, mind you, although it is just a title, I was not the Assistant), I thought of it as a real job. Not permanent, but definitely something worthwhile doing. As it is now, most of the gears in my life are aligned to keep me here, despite an inner pressure to return home and start my “real” life.

Q: Are there any people who ever jump ship and return to their home country before the program is over? What are some of the reasons they chose to leave?

Sadly, there are ALTs who break their contract and leave early for a variety of reasons. I don’t like to talk too much about them because some of them are very tragic stories. But some reasons I’ve heard is that the stress of living in Japan can suddenly become very strong. I’ve noticed two large time periods were people experience the worst of it. November/December and May.

Q: Could you elaborate just a bit on the Nov/Dec thing? Like, what is this the half-year point or what? Or is it the weather?

Well, in my experience, November and December are really tough for Westerners, specifically Americans, because of the holidays, Thanksgiving and Christmas. Sometimes it can be really disheartening to look around and realize that one is all alone. I suppose it doesn’t help that many ALTs actually teach those holidays in their own class so they have to really realize that the safety net of the family is gone. That sense of isolation and aloneness does hit people in many different ways. I’ve found that most people don’t miss the big things from home unless they’ve been here a while.

For example, I love driving and I love my car back in America. But when I came to Japan, I knew that I wouldn’t drive at all and also that I wouldn’t see my car and I mentally prepared myself for that, so it wasn’t a large problem. But things hit really hard when ALTs call home and they’re reminded of all the little things that they hadn’t prepared on missing. Their family is together. The smell of the kitchen as Mom serves her family’s apple pie that’s been the family recipe for generations, ever since the Angles met the Saxons. Sparky the dog just swallowed the entire turkey. The family or friends are having a great time, even moving on,despite that the ALT isn’t there. Pictures from back home are being sent to each ALT and it’s just a harsh reminder that the ALT is out here, not even able to celebrate properly. There aren’t many turkeys or cranberries in Japan. And McDonald’s apple pie is a very pale substitute.

After those depressing months, the JET participants have to decide if they will re-contract or not by February. Many ALTs think their situation will stay the exact same, and so make that decision based on how they feel after a few short months of teaching. But in April, the education system does what I call “The Great Shuffle” in which teachers throughout the schools are shifted around all over the city, creating a totally different experience for ALTs. It can get really bad (awesome teachers leave for different schools and bad teachers can come in) or it can get really good (new awesome teachers totally befriend and take care of the ALT, there’s more acceptance of English).

May is around the time that it sinks in what the next term (maybe even year) will be like. I have dealt with ALTs deciding to go home, and then in April, their school becomes really great and manageable. The ALT then wants to stay, but can’t, because the paperwork has already been sent to CLAIR. I’ve also dealt with the opposite situation, where the school was great in February, and the ALT re-contracted. But then in April, things get worse. Of course, these are extreme examples. Most of the time, it’s something in between.

Q: What advice would you give to people who are considering the JET application, but haven’t quite made up their mind yet?

Apply and be professional! It’s a fun job, but it’s a job nonetheless. Even though the Japanese are big on drinking, they are not big on drinking in the total college-student irresponsible fashion. Remember that the drunk driving blood alcohol level is 0.0. Absolutely no alcohol in the bloodstream. The stories that people do hear are extreme few-and-far-between type stories.

Be fun and open-minded on your application. Write your essay from a standpoint of awe and wonder at the world, not from a standpoint of arrogance and know-it-all. Be honest. I knew nothing about Japan or teaching and I still got in, so don’t think you need to sell your knowledge of either. If you have any doubts about the program itself, just apply anyway.

Q: Any regrets in the decision to join JET and come to Japan?

No. I love being here, but sometimes I do want to go back and get on with my life. On the flip side, I don’t know what I would do back home and plus I’m having a great experience here.

Q: Three years is a long time. Any plans to go home?

Not yet, unfortunately. I do want to go back, but there are still too many things I want to see and do in Japan. After that, who knows? I may be stuck in Japan for the rest of my life, or I may get to live all over the world. The family isn’t too happy about those possibilities, but everyone has to make their own choices sometime in their life.

Thanks for your time Sugu!

Official JET homepage

GuruSugu.com – Sugu’s website

  • http://www.victorymanual.com Alex

    I read all of the parts, but I have one point of criticism directed at Mr. Sugu, and it directly contradicts the “Learner Stories” that Will over at nihongojouzu.com conducts.

    Mr. Sugu continued to insist that applicants should be nothing but professional on the job, but he implicitly denies working in Japan is a “real living”.

    despite an inner pressure to return home and start my “real” life.

    Most of the ‘learners’ in “Learner Stories” are former JETs who have moved on to bigger and better things in Japan, like translation work.

    Of course JET work itself is limited to officially 3 years (or unofficially more if directly invited by the school…), but I don’t think that pursuing a career in Japan for 3 or more years is “an excuse to stay making good money and do nothing.” And if someone who does nothing gets invited to recontract, it really shows a flaw in the JET system.

  • http://www.gurusugu.com Sugu

    Hi Alex,

    Sorry about the confusion but that quote of mine was actually a reference to the pressure I get from back home. Family, friends, etc. who have said my life is a bubble out here, protected and sheltered. As for me, I am making a real living out here. My girlfriend has since left JET and moved on to greener pastures, and is so far having a great time. My point about the whole thing is that I do treat my job and my life here with as much professionalism as I can, but it is also apparent to me that many ALTs do not share that viewpoint. Professionalism is an attitude, not necessarily a position or ranking. So even though I am not planning on making Japan my permanent home, JET my permanent job, etc., I can still be professional here. Frankly though, in my definition of “career”, it is impossible to make a career out of the JET Programme in Japan. Even now, they’ve extended the cap to 5 years (for ALTs that do well in the evaluation), but that still isn’t a career as it is more a job, and more specifically, contract work. Oh, and btw, I agree that the JET Programme has flaws, like any other massive bureaucracy. Some flaws are greater than others.

  • Lisa

    Thank you Harvey for the interviews. They were very interesting and informative as always. Could you clarify something for me” I was confused by the following statements:

    “I want to leave and go back to the States (I’ve only been back once in 3 years and that was not the best experience), but I can’t.” AND “Not yet, unfortunately. I do want to go back, but there are still too many things I want to see and do in Japan.” Does he want to go back to the US but also wants to stay in Japan voluntarily (he is torn by his desire to be in both countries) or does he really just want to go back to the US but must stay in Japan due to obligations. I think the “unfortunately…” confused me as to if he really wanted to go to stay.

  • Simon T

    Sounds like you’re having a more productive time than I did as a CIR in Kochi, Shikoku.

    I thought I’d landed the dream job as a CIR when, at last, I could put more than 10 years, 2 universities, and 3 private school’s worth of language and studies on Japan to good use…

    Instead, I spent the whole year playing on the internet as my office really had no idea of how to make best use of the skills/training I had to offer.

    Participating in many of JET’s ‘well-meaning” seminars soon revealed I was not the only one.

    I volunteered for ‘work’ just to relieve the bordom. However, I did more for ‘international relations’ & ‘cross-cultural understanding’ in the outside of work in the local bars/restaurants where I really connected with the local community.

    So where am I today? Putting those years of skills & knowledge to work, at long last, in a country where I really can make a difference… CHINA!

    Quite ironic considering the Japanese government paid for almost half of my education!

  • http://www.japannewbie.com harvey

    Simon! I’m curious to know what you’re doing in China! Are you teaching? Or doing something else? Did the sudden earnings change from Yen to Yuan shock your system at all? That’s one thing that crosses my mind every time I consider what it would be like to make the move… Anyway, hope Simon notices this post and responds! :)

    I have casually studied Chinese myself, and visited Beijing (and Taiwan… China? A debate for another time, another place) and loved it!

    Regarding the comment on JET preferring people who speak no Japanese… I have heard that before as well. It’s interesting. The monbusho (MEXT) scholarship which is another J-government system to get gaijin in Japan on the other hand seems to give preference to students who can speak Japanese well, and are familiar with Japan.

    I guess when coming over as a JET, the more you already know about Japan, the less of a “gaijin shock” you’ll give the school/city you are sent to, thus reducing the impact? I have also heard that for similar reasons that more “gaijin-looking gaijin” will often be selected before gaijin of Asian decent… Though I do know 2nd and 3rd gen Japanese who have been selected for, and done well on JET… So I dunno. Maybe just rumors.

    Wow the JET cap has been extended from 3 to 5 years? Wow. I didn’t know that. Maybe it’s just me and my hyper-active nature… But I couldn’t imagine being a JET/CIR for 5 consecutive years. Maybe if they allowed you to switch cities or something in the middle… But 5 years is a long long time to be “the gaijin” in a school district.

    Thanks for all the great comments everyone, this is a lot of fun!

  • http://www.nihongojouzu.com Will

    Harvey – cool work with the interview.

    Alex – I understand your point (and thanks for the plug!) but I can also see Sugu’s side – JET can become a career launcher, but it can also be a breathing space between jobs, and I don’t mean that in a derogatory way, simply that given it is an exchange programme the idea is to experience Japan and then go home and tell everyone about it. Having said that there are always those fools like Harvey and me who fall in love with the place and forget to go home, so Japan becomes home…..

    BTW Harvey – can a fella get a Blogroll link!?

    cheers

    Will

  • http://www.japannewbie.com harvey

    Will – You’re linked!

  • http://www.gurusugu.com Sugu

    Wow, I started a big discussion here! Thanks for all your comments! To respond to Lisa’s comment, truth be told, I am quite conflicted about it. Both of your thoughts are correct. There are a lot of things I still want to see and do in Japan, so I want to stay. I want to travel more, and see a few more festivals that I haven’t gotten around to. On the other hand, there are certain things I really miss about being back home. I miss being in an English-speaking country. I miss driving. I miss free shipping from Amazon.com. At the same time, there are obligations that I have here, both to myself and to others. There are things I feel a need to finish and accomplish here that aren’t JET related before I can return back home. So in the end, I’m incredibly torn. I want to stay, I want to go, and I need to stay.

  • http://www.gurusugu.com Sugu

    Hi Simon,

    That’s awesome that you’re in China now. Are you doing translation work out there?

    This is where things get a bit complicated. Harvey calls me a CIR, but in reality, I’m not. I’m part ALT (Assistant Language Teacher), part PA (Prefectural Advisor), part CIR (Coordinator for International Relations), all rolled up into one. My title is actually that of ALT Coordinator. Our CIRs (we have 2 in Hamamatsu) are busy in the public eye. I’m busy taking care of ALTs and making sure their lives run smoothly. My Japanese is nowhere near fluent, but it gets me and my ALTs by. That’s actually why I’ve had to deal with legal issues. ALTs get themselves into a lot of different situations that my boss and I have to help them out. More productive? Well, definitely busier. Everyday is different at the office and I have a ton of “war stories” now. Unfortunately, I haven’t had much time to update my website in a long time. I think my last update was to welcome the LAST crop of ALTs!

JapanNewbie
    Twitter Feed

Welcome to JapanNewbie.com! My goal is to get you excited about Japan and the Japanese language. Love it! This blog has been around for more than five years now, so be sure to dig into the archives and use the search. You never know what you might find!

Recent Comments:




  • Photos on flickr